As Tesco puts Pampers in its sights, is "product" the battleground of the future?

Tesco's introduction of products from its new "Tesco Loves Baby" brand isn't on the face of it particularly startling news. After all, own brand products have been increasingly favoured by consumers across the board and, even in this particular category, the supermarket has long been active both with its own-brand products and its Tesco Baby Club, now rebranded the Tesco Loves Baby Club. The landscape of nappies is clearly radically changing as the classic choice between Pampers and Huggies is no longer going to be possible. So not only does the addition of the word "loves" mark another stage in Tesco's drive to cosy up to their customers more warmly, but this assertive step into the space left by Huggies could be the start of something bigger. There are suggestions within the media that with this new departure Tesco might be looking to seriously challenge the dominance of P&G's Pampers. However, in this of all categories, Tesco or any other own label may have to find themselves working particularly hard to convince consumers that branded is not (even just a little bit) better. With nappies, consumers may need concrete evidence to switch from a branded product whereas in other categories even within baby – for example, wipes – there may be more willingness to go own label, even if the product were not quite as good, if there is an appreciable cost saving. If this is the case and Tesco were to be successful in turning its own brand nappies into a market leader, will consumers start to seek out own-brand-brands in certain categories, because of their product characteristics and not just their value? With just a hint of poacher turned gamekeeper, own brands will have become the brand. Will this, in turn, mark a shift to consumers focusing more clearly on product intrinsics at the expense of or in spite of brand extrinsics as they "get by" without the expensive surround sound of brand noise. This could just mean that brands need to work harder in the way they communicate and emotionally connect with people (i.e. better extrinsics); but it could also imply that product innovation is more important than ever. If the product is demonstrably superior, then brands will retain their favoured status over "cheaper" own label. At Engage we work extensively in npd and have been using more experiential programmes bringing clients and consumers together to help create highly refined products which will compete assertively with own label competition. If the battleground of the future is product excellence & uniqueness at the premium end and product quality at the value end, the way that products are developed and the co-creative involvement of consumers will be more critical than ever.